Case Package Export
Generated 14 March 2025
Civil Protection Order — Case Package
Applicant v. Respondent • Application ref. CPO-2024-4817
Executive Summary
Case Type
Civil Protection Order
Filed
05 December 2024
Status
Full order granted
Order Date
14 March 2025
Documents Analysed
7
Contradictions
3 identified (2 HIGH, 1 MED)
Key Finding
"Pattern of coercive behaviour documented across multiple independent sources, with respondent's own statements contradicting objective evidence on at least three occasions."
Timeline
5 key events14 March 2025 Order Granted
Full Protection Order Granted
24-month duration. Includes no-contact provision, 100-metre exclusion zone around applicant's residence, and prohibition on third-party contact.
22 February 2025 Breach
Respondent Breached Interim Order
Attended applicant's property at 23:40. CCTV footage from neighbouring property confirms presence at approximately 18 metres from front door. Interim order specified 100-metre exclusion zone.
08 December 2024 Interim Order
Interim Protection Order Granted
Court granted interim order pending full hearing. Conditions include no direct or indirect contact, 100-metre exclusion zone, and surrender of keys.
05 December 2024 Filed
Application Filed
Civil protection order application submitted with supporting police report (ref: IR-2024-8831), two witness statements, and photographic evidence.
01 December 2024 Medical
GP Report Documenting Injuries
General practitioner examination documenting injuries consistent with reported incident. Report referenced in application but original document awaiting upload.
Evidence Index
7 documents| Document | Type | Date | Status | Key Facts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Police Incident Report IR-2024-8831 | 01 Dec 2024 | Approved | 8 | |
| Witness Statement — M. O'Brien | 03 Dec 2024 | Approved | 5 | |
| Witness Statement — K. Dunne | 04 Dec 2024 | Approved | 4 | |
| CCTV Still — 22 Feb Breach | Image | 22 Feb 2025 | Approved | 3 |
| Threatening Email — 28 Nov 2024 | 28 Nov 2024 | Approved | 3 | |
| Photographs — Property Damage | Image | 30 Nov 2024 | Approved | 2 |
| GP Medical Report | 01 Dec 2024 | Pending | — |
Contradictions Identified
3 found
HIGH
Social Media Contact
Respondent stated under oath that there had been "no contact of any kind" with the applicant since the interim order. However, 14 Instagram direct messages were sent from the respondent's verified account to the applicant between 12 December 2024 and 18 January 2025.
Respondent Affidavit, para. 12
Instagram Message Screenshots (referenced)
HIGH
Distance Restriction Violation
CCTV footage from the neighbouring property timestamps the respondent at approximately 18 metres from the applicant's front door at 23:40 on 22 February 2025. The interim order specified a 100-metre exclusion zone. Respondent claims to have been at a different location that evening.
CCTV Still — 22 Feb Breach
Interim Order, Condition 3
Respondent Affidavit, para. 18
MEDIUM
Date Discrepancy in Respondent's Account
Respondent's affidavit states the relationship ended "in early October 2024," but the threatening email dated 28 November 2024 references ongoing cohabitation and shared finances, suggesting the relationship continued for at least two months beyond the stated end date.
Respondent Affidavit, para. 4
Threatening Email — 28 Nov 2024
Key Quotes
5 extractedI could hear shouting from next door at approximately 11 p.m. It was not the first time. This had been happening on and off for at least six months.
Witness Statement — M. O'Brien
Page 1, para. 3
The patient presented with bruising to the left forearm and upper right shoulder consistent with gripping injuries. The patient reported these injuries were sustained during a domestic incident.
GP Medical Report (referenced)
Page 1, Examination Findings
You know what will happen if you go to anyone about this. I will make sure nobody believes you.
Threatening Email — 28 Nov 2024
Email body, line 4
I saw him standing across the road from the house at around half eleven at night. I recognised him immediately. He was looking up at the windows.
Witness Statement — K. Dunne
Page 2, para. 1
I have had no contact of any kind with the applicant since the date of the interim order and have fully complied with all conditions.
Respondent Affidavit
Page 3, para. 12
Strategic Gaps
3 identified
GP medical report referenced but not uploaded.
The police report and application both reference the GP examination of 01 December 2024, but the original report has not been added to the case file. This is a critical piece of corroborating medical evidence.
The police report and application both reference the GP examination of 01 December 2024, but the original report has not been added to the case file. This is a critical piece of corroborating medical evidence.
Instagram message screenshots not in evidence.
14 messages are referenced but the actual screenshots have not been uploaded. Without these, the social media contact contradiction relies on an oral account only.
14 messages are referenced but the actual screenshots have not been uploaded. Without these, the social media contact contradiction relies on an oral account only.
Third-party witness for February breach not yet contacted.
The CCTV was obtained from a neighbouring property. A statement from that neighbour confirming they provided the footage voluntarily would strengthen the chain of evidence.
The CCTV was obtained from a neighbouring property. A statement from that neighbour confirming they provided the footage voluntarily would strengthen the chain of evidence.
Recommended Next Steps
Obtain police incident report for February breach.
CCTV evidence and witness statement from K. Dunne are uploaded. The police report is referenced but not yet in the case file.
CCTV evidence and witness statement from K. Dunne are uploaded. The police report is referenced but not yet in the case file.
Obtain Instagram message screenshots from police disclosure.
Request under disclosure obligations or directly from the applicant's device. These directly contradict paragraph 12 of the respondent's affidavit.
Request under disclosure obligations or directly from the applicant's device. These directly contradict paragraph 12 of the respondent's affidavit.
Request GP report from applicant's general practitioner.
Medical evidence of injuries will corroborate the police report and strengthen the application record for any future proceedings.
Medical evidence of injuries will corroborate the police report and strengthen the application record for any future proceedings.